Showing posts with label AMD1PB - Group 6B. Show all posts
Showing posts with label AMD1PB - Group 6B. Show all posts

Thursday, September 2, 2010

The Problem with Written Constitution

Geez, we are not so sure about the problem with the written constitution. Whether the constitution is written or not, it doesn’t matter right ?
For us, the underlying main problem is the constitutionalism. Having written constitution doesn’t mean that your country is systematic enough, and having no written constitution ( unwritten constitution ) also doesn’t mean that your country is in wreak-havoc.
It is just a matter of constitutionalism or not. Am I right ?
Subjectively, we see that there are 3 situations.
1.       Having written constitution – having constitutionalism
2.       Having written constitution – having no constitutionalism
3.       Having no written constitution - ? ( need to ask miss Fisha again lol )
Let’s say there is a country A, and it has the written constitution. Now, at this stake, it depends on the ruler also. The ruler want to follow the constitution or not, it depends.
“should not be taken to mean that if a state has a constitution, it is necessarily committed to the idea of constitutionalism. In a very real sense… every state may be said to have a constitution, since every state has institutions which are at the very least expected to be permanent, and every state has established ways of doing things." But even with a "formal written document labeled 'constitution' which includes the provisions customarily found in such a document, it does not follow that it is committed to constitutionalism. “ ~ David Fellman

Thursday, August 5, 2010

The Republic of Kosovo

Kosovo is a republic country  which has a de facto independancy and is located in the south east side of Europe. Before this, Kosovo was a province in Serbia under the administration of  the United Nations. The heart of Kosovo is in Pristina. The independency of Kosovo was acknowledge by Albania, US, France and Turkey. On the contrary Russia and Serbia did not agree.

The International Court of Justice delivered its advisory opinion on 22 July 2010 and concluded that the declaration of independence of Kosovo "did not violate any applicable rule of international law".

International law specialists noted that, although the ICJ (International court of justice) decided Kosovo’s declaration was legal. Kosovo’s declaration of independence also meant Kosovo, as a state, was a legitimate internationally recognized nation. As a result of this ruling, both Kosovars and Serbs can find some grounds to declare a victory of some sort in the long-running dispute.

Serbs, for whom Kosovo is an ancestral homeland and the site of many important Serbian Orthodox churches and monasteries, insist that the area remain under Serbian sovereignty. Broader opposition to separating Kosovo from Serbia stems from concern about the potential precedent that would be set by redrawing boundaries along ethnic lines and the likely impact this move would have on the integrity of the borders of Macedonia, Montenegro, and Bosnia.

Ethnicity
Nevertheless, harsh realities on the ground make independence for Kosovo the only viable option. In the current state of unstability, relations between the Albanian majority, which is mostly Muslim, and the Serbian minority, which is mostly Orthodox Christian, have reached the boiling point. The Albanian leadership in Pristina, which governs Kosovo in an uneasy partnership with UN authorities, wants nothing to do with Belgrade. Kosovo has already left Serbia's orbit.In spirit as well as fact, multi-ethnic society is nowhere to be found.

In a meeting with Kosovo prime minister Hashim Thaci, American vice president Joe Biden “reaffirmed the United States' full support for an independent, democratic, whole and multi-ethnic Kosovo whose future lies firmly within European and Euro-Atlantic institutions”.

Money
Thaci also received good news from the International Monetary Fund when the IMF approved a loan package of $140 million for infrastructure construction and reconstruction, in addition to nearly twice that amount already available from the World Bank and the European Commission.
 () In explaining the Serb position, President Boris Tadic added, “If the ICJ opinion establishes a new principle, an entire process of creating new states would open throughout the world, something that would destabilize many regions of the world.”

We also think that the independancy of Kosovo will give inspiration to other small regions of the world to fight for their independency. Whereas the original country, like Kosovo before this was under Serbia as the main country will become unsatisfied with the separation and independency of the state.


Now that they have independency, they are free from outside control and thus, manage their own country.

" The true character of liberty is independence, maintained by force. " ~ Voltaire

[ el ferdowsi ( Firdaus ), Pian Yank, Bunny, Fatin Liyana, pizah, Liza Kecik, Mama of 6B ]

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Purposes of the state

Before the legitimate government exist, man was a nation unto himself. To reduce his responsibility, he then formed a centralized power with the others. They agreed to give up the sole right on part of their property. Thus, government exists is not to be your big brother, but to protect your property. This opinion is solely based on John Locke's ideas of government.

Not that just all, government also exist to align the system to suit and control the people in each side of sociology, politic and economy. Human is dynamic being that has different ideas, thus leading to different law and custom, -- and government, is a simply become the solution, play its part as a legitimate solver to any agreement-disagreement with one another.

analogy : You and your brother are having conflict among both of you. You, and you brother agree to let your parents helping you all in solving this matter. Get what I mean ? Yeah, parents are like goverment. ;)

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

On legitimacy, authority, and sovereignity.


Legitimacy.
We took a long time in trying to understand the real meaning of legitimacy. We’ve actually even need to open the dictionary ‘Collins Cobuild’ to look out its meaning.
‘Legitimacy’  (nouns) : something is acceptable according to the law.
Digging more into every ways to gain legitimacy, seems like government shall not lived by approval from the citizens itself. What sort of government that don’t have any support from its citizens? Government, albeit its corruption or any conflicts that exist in Malaysia, shall ever not live – without the concerns by the citizens itself – that is us. 

My respond:
Why don't the government shall not lived by approval from the citizens itself? What about the government that come into power through coup de tat? They don't necessarily need to seek approval from people, but force people to accept them. For Malaysian government case, I think to pick the lesser between two evils is more appropriate =p

Take one example, government, without enough resources, just say it money, shall having a problem in managing one community or peoples. Go far away from this, then you’ll realize that human only needs what have been stated in Maslow’s hierarchy ( foods, habitat, sex, and etc. ). Approval. Approval right? Well, just in case we do not want Malaysian government shall be called as regime. This country, democracy and liberty are filled into it, in avoidance to become dictatorial leadership.

Err .. .what this has to do with legitimacy? And, I think, in the name of legitimacy, then the government did what they do ... the people? With the apathetic attitudes? Blerghhh ... gimme a break!
Ironically, take a deep look around you, and you will realize that people does not want the good government in this country, they only want the government that can provide them with a good place, good food, and yeah, good fat money on their pockets. They don’t care about the integrity, they don’t care about the policy, they’re just care about their money. Bad society will produce a bad leader. Changing our attitudes is not late yet. Trust us my friends. ;)

Uuuu .. such a strong words you used. How would you spell the integrity of government? And, "Bad society will produce a bad leader" is another implied confession? Irony? I'd say that. 

Authority.
At first we actually think that we’ve grasp the definition of authority, but then again – when it comes to chapter 2, based on Roskin’s quote ,
“ Authority is an individual’s ability to gain respect or loyalty from people.”
How can we understand that when we already learn that the concept of respect or loyalty is actually related to INFLUENCE ?
Taking too seriously we think, on that definition – somehow we need to realize that there is always, always the meaning of these three things, ( power, authority, influence ) shall interchangeably used.
This remind us, about the simple example to describe. Take an armed robber, a teacher and a businessman.  Respectively, in this case, you shall quickly realize that armed robber is the symbol of real power, the teacher is the symbol of authority and thus, businessman, is to the influence. When you are being robbed, like it or not – they are the one who have a greater force or coercion upon you, shall have the real power. Differs to the idea of authority, authority deals with law enforcement. Legally generated. Legally enforced. Legally executed. It’s all about playing with law and policies. So what about businessman ? Well, after all, businessman cannot force you to buy his product right ? Nor they don’t have any law with them that states that it is compulsory to us to buy his product right ? So what they actually trying to do,  is, indirectly, persuading you to buy it. Owh yes, persuasive way. That’s what we call influence. But don’t limit this three terms into this concept only. Real power doesn’t mean that it only about force and coercion. Generally, when it comes to ‘power’, its subset is only real power, authority, and influence. Aih… just don’t care too much about the definition, pays more to the pragmatic things in this political science. We don’t bother theories too much, what we need is just a practical way to solve any issues related to this human matter.
Yeah ... different people have different opinions ... so does the definition. But, to play safe, just stick to those definitions given, OK?

Sovereignity.
Talk about sovereignity, we still on confusion of supreme power versus constitutional monarchy. Lets say that there is a king, whom have unlimited power – now that’s what we call the supreme power. We don’t call it as supreme if it is limited and the king cannot doing anything freely don’t we?
Thinking again - and just listened to what our lecturer have said, “We call it supreme because based on the historical data.”
*then she pointed out once upon a time about the king that slash the woman stomach that had eaten the a piece of a jackfruit without his permission*,
the king always has the unlimited power. Supreme because in this historical context. That’s all. Historical terms limit.
After all, this is just – simply a view of some novice. Don’t take these too seriously, otherwise, you might be confused. Will you?  ;)


 "Just because you do not take an interest in politics, doesn’t mean politics won’t take an interest in you." ~ Pericles (430 BC)

[ el ferdowsi ( Firdaus ), Pian Yank, Bunny, Fatin Liyana, pizah, Liza Kecik, Mama of 6B ]